Best Pizza in Birmingham
Oliver Bancroft l Last Updated: September 4, 2026
How We Selected the Best Pizza in Birmingham?
Choosing the best pizza restaurants involves more than simply comparing Google star ratings. We considered several factors when assessing the businesses included in this guide:
Pizza Quality – The style of pizza, dough preparation, cooking method and overall menu offering.
Ingredients & Dough – The use of quality ingredients, fresh dough and recognised Italian ingredients where applicable.
Cooking Method – Traditional, wood-fired and high-temperature pizza preparation methods were considered.
Menu Choice – Variety of pizzas, vegetarian options, vegan choices and other relevant menu options.
Accessibility & Location – Convenience for customers visiting Birmingham city centre and surrounding neighbourhoods.
Reputation & Reviews – Publicly available customer ratings, review volume and recurring feedback.
Dining Experience – Atmosphere, service, suitability for groups and the overall experience offered.
Birmingham has a varied pizza scene, with independent pizzerias and established pizza restaurants serving everything from traditional Neapolitan-style pizzas to wood-fired and contemporary interpretations. For diners, the choice can come down to more than simply finding a restaurant with a high rating.
Whether you are looking for a classic Margherita, a charred Neapolitan crust, creative toppings or a relaxed place for dinner, Birmingham has several options worth considering. Location, pizza style, ingredient quality, service and overall dining experience can all make a difference.
This guide brings together five Birmingham pizza restaurants that stand out based on their publicly available reputation, pizza offering, customer feedback, location and the quality of information available about their food and services.
The selection is intended to help different types of diners compare established city-centre pizzerias with independent neighbourhood restaurants. It may be useful for anyone planning a casual meal, family visit, date night or simply looking for a good pizza in Birmingham.
Please note: This guide is for general information and comparison purposes. Being included on this list does not constitute a recommendation or guarantee of a particular outcome.
1. Rudy's Pizza Napoletana
Address: 9–10 Bennetts Hill, Birmingham, B2 5RS, United Kingdom
Contact: +44 121 314 5880
Rudy's Pizza Napoletana brings traditional Neapolitan-style pizza to Birmingham city centre. Its Bennetts Hill restaurant is located close to New Street Station, the Bullring and the city's main shopping and business areas, making it convenient for both visitors and local diners.
The restaurant focuses on traditionally prepared pizza, with dough made using 00 Caputo flour and fermented for up to 24 hours. Its pizzas use ingredients including San Marzano tomatoes and fior di latte mozzarella, with the pizzas cooked at high temperatures to produce a soft, airy crust with a light char.
The Birmingham restaurant also caters for different dining occasions, from casual lunches and dinners to larger group gatherings. Vegan and vegetarian choices are available, while click-and-collect, delivery and private-hire options add flexibility for different customers.
🍕 What You’ll Find
🍕 Neapolitan pizza
🌾 Fresh dough made with 00 Caputo flour
🍅 San Marzano tomato pizzas
🧀 Fior di latte mozzarella
🌱 Vegetarian pizzas
🌿 Vegan pizza options
🥡 Click-and-collect
🛵 Pizza delivery
🎉 Group dining
🎈 Private hire
📶 Free Wi-Fi
♿ Accessible facilities
Why Consider Rudy's Pizza Napoletana?
Rudy's is a strong option for diners specifically looking for traditional Neapolitan pizza in a convenient Birmingham city-centre location.
Best for: Diners looking for traditional Neapolitan pizza with a broad choice of classic and contemporary toppings.
Operating Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 11:30am–9:30pm
Friday - Saturday: 11:30am–10:00pm
Sunday: 11:30am–9:00pm
⭐ 4.6/5 Ratings — 2,706 Reviews
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
I have been to Rudy’s many times over the years and always had a good experience.
Last time, we came in for a takeaway pizza. Eric at the front desk gave us really good advice on how to reheat the pizza at home later so it tastes the best. And it worked! I will be definitely coming back again, hopefully for many years more. Picture with this review is from 2025 😊
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Amazing staff! Came in on valentine's day without a reservation and they sat us at the bar. Service was lightning speed and our waitresses were friendly, checking in on us. Before leaving, someone came over and said that a delivery order had not been picked up, so they gave us free tiramisu to-go as a treat! Thank you whoever it was for choosing us, it was the best way to wrap up a memorable day.
2. Pizza Pilgrims Birmingham
Address: Grand Central Shopping Centre, New St, Station, Birmingham, B2 4BF, United Kingdom
Contact: +44 121 803 8229
Pizza Pilgrims Birmingham is located within Grand Central, directly above the New Street Station concourse. The location makes it particularly convenient for people travelling through Birmingham, shopping in the city centre or looking for a pizza restaurant close to the Bullring.
The pizzeria specialises in Neapolitan pizza made using double-fermented dough and ingredients sourced from Italy. Its pizzas are baked at around 500°C, producing a light, chewy and charred crust. The menu includes traditional options alongside more unusual combinations such as Double Pepperoni & Spicy Honey and Carbonara pizza.
Pizza Pilgrims also offers vegetarian, vegan and halal options, as well as takeaway and click-and-collect. The restaurant accepts bookings while keeping much of its seating available for walk-in customers.
🍕What You’ll Find
🍕 Neapolitan pizza
🌾 72-hour double-fermented dough
🔥 High-temperature pizza cooking
🌱 Vegan options
🥬 Vegetarian options
🥩 Halal options
🥡 Takeaway
📦 Click-and-collect
👨👩👧 Family-friendly dining
🎉 Group bookings
🐕 Dog-friendly dining
♿ Accessible facilities
Why Consider Pizza Pilgrims Birmingham?
Its combination of Neapolitan-style pizza, central location and varied menu makes it particularly convenient for city-centre diners and visitors arriving through New Street Station.
Best for: City-centre diners, travellers and groups looking for Neapolitan pizza with vegetarian, vegan and halal options.
Operating Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 11:30am–9:00pm
Friday: 11:30am–10:00pm
Saturday: 11:00am–10:00pm
Sunday: 12:00pm–8:00pm
- 🍕 Strong focus on Neapolitan-style pizza
- 🌾 Uses long-fermented dough and high-temperature cooking
- 🥩 Halal options are available
- 📍 Extremely convenient Birmingham city-centre location
- 🚉 The restaurant's station location can make it a busy environment.
- 📅 Customer feedback indicates that service can vary during busy periods.
- 💷 Some diners may find the overall meal relatively expensive compared with basic pizza takeaways.
⭐ 4.8/5 Ratings — 1,551 Reviews
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Came with my friend for some relaxing time and pizza, and it was honestly amazing, the food was fresh, delicious and don't get me started on Jess, she was so adorable and friendly, had a laugh and joked around, (LOVE HER SO SO SOOOOOO MUCHHHH) will definitely come back for her!!! 😝💕✌🏻
Definitely recommend this place for some authentic italian pizza!!!!
💖😽
- Super
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Had a really great experience at Pizza Pilgrims! The service was quick and friendly, with Anna and Liam doing a fantastic job making us feel welcome and looked after. The food came out fast and was absolutely delicious, you can really taste the quality. I loved the pesto aioli with the pizza, I’d go back just for that alone! Highly recommend if you’re after great pizza and even better service.
- K K
3. Otto Pizza
Address: 15 Caroline Street, Jewellery Quarter, Birmingham, B3 1TR, United Kingdom
Contact: +44 121 233 3370
Otto Pizza is an independent pizzeria in Birmingham's Jewellery Quarter, close to St Paul's Square. The restaurant focuses on pizza alongside a wider selection of small plates, charcuterie, vegetable boards, desserts, wine and cocktails.
Its pizza menu includes a mixture of classic and more distinctive combinations, with the restaurant's dough and wood-fired cooking receiving frequent positive comments in publicly available customer reviews. The setting is designed as a neighbourhood restaurant rather than a traditional takeaway, making it suitable for sit-down meals and social occasions.
Otto also offers collection and delivery through Deliveroo, while table bookings are available for its Jewellery Quarter restaurant. Its location and menu make it an option for customers who want pizza alongside drinks, sharing plates and a more relaxed restaurant experience.
🍕 What You’ll Find
🍕 Pizza
🔥 Wood-fired pizza
🥗 Vegetable boards
🧀 Charcuterie
🍽️ Small plates
🍰 Desserts
🍷 Wine
🍸 Cocktails
🥡 Takeaway
🛵 Delivery
📅 Table bookings
🌱 Vegetarian options
Why Consider Otto Pizza?
Otto is worth considering for diners who want an independent Jewellery Quarter pizzeria with distinctive pizzas and a broader sit-down dining menu.
Best for: Couples, groups and pizza lovers looking for an independent restaurant experience in Birmingham's Jewellery Quarter.
Operating Hours:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday - Thursday: 5:00pm–9:00pm
Friday: 5:00pm–9:30pm
Saturday: 12:00pm–9:30pm
Sunday: 12:00pm–5:30pm
- 🍕 Independent pizzeria with a dedicated pizza menu.
- 🔥 Wood-fired pizza is a central part of the offering.
- 🧀 Offers charcuterie and vegetable boards alongside pizza.
- 🍷 Wine and cocktails complement the food menu.
- 🌱 Vegetarian choices are available.
- 🌙 Weekday opening starts in the evening.
- 📅 Booking ahead may be useful during busy periods.
- 💷 Prices are generally above basic takeaway pizza.
⭐ 4.7/5 Ratings — 962 Reviews
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
I visited with my boyfriend the other day and it was 10/10! The restaurant itself is so cute, it was a lovely warm day and the door was open letting the sunshine in - just adding to the atmosphere. The gentleman that served us was really friendly and made us feel very at ease, and the food was amazing! The ingredients were fresh and tasty and you can see it all being made in front of you. Also for the dips they provided the portions were very generous which was a big positive for me as some places give such a small amount! Prices were very reasonable and I would definitely return.
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Always a lovely 🍕 experience. Food is consistently spot on. Pretty much the only place where I look forward to having the salad which is amazing here.
Very nicely curated wine list too.
Make sure you book as it gets busy.
4. Smoke + Ash Pizzeria
Address: 12 Greenfield Crescent, Edgbaston Village, Birmingham, B15 3AU, United Kingdom
Contact: +44 121 454 9544
Smoke + Ash is an independent neighborhood pizzeria based in Edgbaston Village. The restaurant focuses on Neapolitan-style pizza and combines its food menu with quality wines and seasonal twists on classic cocktails.
The menu changes with the seasons, allowing the restaurant to introduce different dishes and pizza combinations throughout the year. Alongside pizza, Smoke + Ash offers Panozzo sandwiches, salads and drinks, creating a broader dining experience than a pizza-only restaurant.
The Edgbaston restaurant is positioned as a relaxed neighborhood venue suitable for casual meals, date nights and catching up with friends. Private functions and pizza-and-cocktail masterclasses are also available.
🍕 What You’ll Find
🍕 Neapolitan-style pizza
🥪 Panuozzo sandwiches
🥗 Fresh salads
🍷 Wine
🍸 Seasonal cocktails
🥡 Food collection
🛵 Food delivery
🎉 Private functions
👨👩👧 Family-friendly dining
🌳 Outdoor seating
🍕 Pizza masterclasses
🥂 Group events
Why Consider Smoke + Ash?
Smoke + Ash is a good option for diners who prefer an independent neighborhood pizzeria combining Neapolitan-style pizza with seasonal food and drinks.
Best for: Diners looking for Neapolitan-style pizza in a relaxed Edgbaston neighborhood setting.
Operating Hours:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 12:00pm–2:00pm
Wednesday: 12:00pm–2:00pm / 5:00pm–9:00pm
Thursday: 12:00pm–2:00pm / 5:00pm–9:00pm
Friday: 12:00pm–2:00pm / 5:00pm–10:00pm
Saturday: 12:00pm–10:00pm
Sunday: 2:00pm–8:00pm
- 🍕 Independent pizzeria with a clear Neapolitan focus.
- 🌿 Seasonal menu approach provides changing food options.
- 🍷 Offers wine and seasonal cocktails alongside pizza.
- 🎉 Private functions and group masterclasses are available.
- 🌳 Outdoor seating is available.
- 📅 Closed on Mondays
- 🕑 Tuesday and some weekday lunch hours are limited.
- 💷 Independent restaurant pricing may be higher than basic takeaway options.
⭐ 4.7/5 Ratings — 419 Reviews
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Had a lovely meal tonight at Smoke + Ash. Rang ahead to see if they could fit us in, and they could. When we arrived we got a warm welcome. The restaurant is cosy and has a nice ambience. The food was next level. Gorgeous burrata salad and amazing chorizo pizza. Really good choice of non and low alcohol drinks and cocktails.
If we're back in the area again, we'll definitely be back.
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Great pizza, cocktails and atmosphere. Eve was helpful, patient and friendly. Service was efficient without being rushed. Had one of the specials, but don’t underestimate the Nutella pizza for dessert too!
5. POMPE Wood Fired Italian Pizzeria
Address: 148 Hawthorn Road, Birmingham, B44 8PX, United Kingdom
Contact: +44 121 448 7447
POMPE is a wood-fired Italian pizzeria based on Hawthorn Road in Birmingham. Its menu includes a broad range of pizzas, from traditional Margherita and Marinara options to more substantial combinations featuring meat, vegetables, seafood and different cheeses.
The restaurant offers a particularly broad selection for diners who want alternatives to standard pizza combinations. Its menu includes options such as Napoletana, Diavola, Quattro Formaggi, Bufala, Fiorentina and several vegetarian and halal pizzas.
POMPE also serves starters, salads, pasta, burgers, wraps, calzones and desserts, making it suitable for groups with different food preferences. Customers can order for collection and takeaway through its online ordering system.
🍕 What You’ll Find
🍕 Wood-fired pizza
🍕 Italian-style pizza
🍅 Margherita pizza
🐟 Seafood pizza
🌱 Vegetarian pizzas
🥩 Halal pizza options
🧀 Quattro Formaggi
🥗 Salads
🍝 Pasta
🥙 Calzones
🍔 Burgers
🍰 Desserts
🥡 Takeaway
📦 Online ordering
Why Consider POMPE Wood Fired Italian Pizzeria?
POMPE stands out for its extensive pizza menu and combination of wood-fired Italian-style pizza with a broad range of meat, vegetarian and halal choices.
Best for: Diners looking for wood-fired pizza with a wide choice of toppings, including vegetarian and halal options.
Operating Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 4:00pm–10:30pm
Friday: 4:00pm–11:00pm
Saturday: 2:00pm–11:00pm
Sunday: 2:00pm–11:00pm
- 🔥 Wood-fired Italian-style pizza.
- 🍕 Very broad pizza menu with many topping combinations.
- 🌱 Extensive vegetarian choices.
- 🥩 Halal pizza choices are available.
- 💷 Several pizzas are positioned at relatively accessible prices.
- 🍝 Offers pasta, calzones, salads and other dishes for groups with different preferences.
- 📍 Located outside Birmingham city centre on Hawthorn Road.
- 🌙 Opening starts in the afternoon on weekdays.
- 🥡 The wider menu may make the restaurant feel more like a broad Italian takeaway/restaurant than a specialist pizzeria.
⭐ 4.8/5 Ratings — 395 Reviews
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Honestly one of the best pizzas I have tried in UK. Highly recommend. Try it you will not regret it. Cheers.
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Pompei Pizza is our family's go-to place for authentic wood-fired pizza! The quality is always excellent, with fresh ingredients, perfectly baked crust, and amazing flavor. Our family favorites are the Pompei Special and the Capricciosa—both are absolutely delicious and never disappoint. The service is friendly, and every visit is a great experience. Highly recommended for anyone looking for fantastic wood-fired pizza!